Baseball Jeremiad


A Curiously Intelligent Baseball blog

Apologia Pro McCarver, Tim

A common pastime of intelligent baseball fans is to complain about the play-by-play men and color commentators on national baseball broadcasts.*

*Let’s leave out local broadcasters in this discussion; some are homers, some are barely able to communication using the English language.

Much vituperation gets directed at FOX’s Tim McCarver.  Granted, McCarver does indeed offer his opinions as if he is being paid by the word.  He can be arrogrant, self-serving and trite in his opinons.  Surely he swoons over stars — he petitioned for the canonization of Albert Pujols at least three times last night — and states the obvious multiple times within the same inning.  I get all that.  For someone who reads Baseball Prospectus regularly or enjoys the intelligent snark of Craig Calcaterra, listening to McCarver, Rick Sutcliffe or Hall of Famer Joe Morgan can be a drag. 

And yet, it’s easy to forget that the majority of baseball fans are not sabermatricians.  Most baseball fans watch baseball for enjoyment and nothing more.  They don’t necessarily understand the intricacies of the game and appreciate McCarver and the rest of his ilk explaining the minutiae that stat heads take for granted. 

As I sat watching innings thirteen through twenty of the Mets/Cardinals last night, I realized that McCarver’s style focuses on the fellow who comes home from a long day of working in his backyard, cracks open a beer and sits down to enjoy the game.

And you know what?  That’s alright with me.  My TV remote has a mute button.  And I use it.

Filed under: Uncategorized, , , ,

The Happy Recap; or, The Vultures Go Hungry

I turned on the Mets game in either the twelfth or thirteenth inning and watched until its conclusion in the twentieth; it was so long ago I cannot recall.

I also have a hard time recalling a game with so many emotional ups and downs.

The Mets Blog has a recap of the game, so I won’t go into details.

However, the game has prompted me to draw a conclusion for which I will be publically castigated — most especially by my co-blogger-in-chief: Tim McCarver ain’t that bad.  In fact, all things considered, he’s pretty darn good considering the audience towards which FOX is programming.  More on this tomorrow…

Meanwhile, the Mets christened Shea Stadium as they buried it on this date in 1964, losing to the Pirates.

Stats of note from the game:

  • Stargell and Clemente went a combined 7 for 10;
  • Bob Friend went the distance for the win;
  • In the beginning of his third season in the big-leagues (but first full season), a 19-year old Ed Kranepool pinch-hit and failed to reach base.

Filed under: Uncategorized, , , , , , , , ,

Baseball Musings

  • Adam Dunn could become only second player ever to have higher number of strikeouts than BA (currently 157 K and .163). First was M Reynolds. 8 years ago
  • At least the New York Times remembers the Expos... 10 years ago
  • MLB Network on Sabathia: "CC is one of the few pitchers in the league who is his own batting eye." 10 years ago
  • Sabathia vs. Halladay tonight: noted hitting hurler Sabathia is hitting .500 against Cy Young winners (okay, he's 1 for 2 against Johan) 10 years ago
  • RT @jaysonst: Now that Stephen Strasburg has pulled into town, the most important era in Nationals history has officially begun. http:// ... 10 years ago

Flickr Photos